There’s a useful and on-point critique of the Maker movement in The Atlantic magazine:  Why I am not a Maker by Debbie Chachra.

And maker devotees and promoters would do well to read it as they out there talking up the maker culture as a panacea to all the ills of education.

But – what is a maker? Just someone who cuts up cardboard, wires up circuits to do amazing things and hacks solutions to practical problems?  Well – of course not.  Although it may include all of those activities.

But it also includes knitters, bakers, quilters, canners, felters, weavers, carpenters, bee-keepers and everyone else out there making stuff.

But this is the bigger issue: Making is a mindset, an approach, a way of seeing the world, an antidote to passivity and spectatorship. So – why not broaden that Maker definition to include all kinds of making and connect making with the world of active and interactive learning? Why limit the definition?

At the recent Poughkeepsie MiniMaker Faire we went way beyond the confines of limiting definitions.  But the edumaker movement -at its best – is way more than even that.

The word poet means maker, composer.

To be a learner you need to be an active participant

To be a maker means to be an active participant in the world: To make it happen.

So makers are people who make “stuff” but they can also make an argument, make a case and – by their words and deeds – make a difference. Intellectual makers make meaning. Activists make change. Leaders make moves and movement. Learners make the world anew. All of us must make a life.

Let’s broaden the definition to those who use their emotional intelligence to make a better, kinder, juster more caring world.

Debbie Chachra  – you are a maker. By making your case you widen the discussion and introduce a number of really important elements that sometimes get lost.

Thank you for making the time to make that case that makes the difference.

Josie Holford

View Comments

Recent Posts

The Affair of the Chocolate Teapot

Midge Hazelbrow, the indomitable co-head of Wayward St. Etheldreda's Academy, took herself for a brisk…

1 month ago

Best Practices, Reading Wars, and Eruption at Wayward

Before the eruption, it was a typical senior leadership meeting at Wayward. Head of School,…

2 months ago

Words Matter

When I taught fourth and fifth grade at a school that didn't assign grades, the…

2 months ago

The Culinary Capers and Comic Catastrophes of Gerald Samper

It was the Gert Loveday review of Rancid Pansies (it’s an anagram) that set me…

2 months ago

Working and Not Working

A post on LinkedIn caught my attention this week.  It's had over 11,000 views so…

2 months ago

Gall, Nerve, Courage, and The Party of Women

 Women's rights campaigner Kellie-Jay Keen of Let Women Speak had a big announcement last week.…

3 months ago